Classes in Tier 5a
PaladinWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - You're supposed to off tank thanks to your healings and charge in on your mount for the smite. Too bad your MAD to do so, assuming you hit. Its better to be the mount.
- The detect evil is worth it for nonBBEGs (who are undetectable). Not worth the aura of good bulls-eye
- Lay on hands isn't effective healing, but its free. The real boost that level is the saves boost.
- The aura is too situational with small range. It almost makes disease immunity look useful
- You can pull significantly late Divine feat use and DMM shenanigans on your pansy spells. Feat tax or MAD.
- Your default mount is a retarded animal companion. You can supermount it, but its not optimal to use the paladin class to even do that.
- Your late SLAs are too situational and too sparse anyways. Wouldn't be the level if it were at will.
[spoiler]
Dead levels:7, 8, 11, 13, 14, 16, 17, 19.
Progression: +1 smite/day per multiple of 5, 1 remove disease/week per multiple of 5, half caster progression starting at 4, mount progression by table and boost every 5 after that.
Class Features: Aura of good+detect evil+smite evil 1/day, Divine grace+lay on hands, Aura of courage+divine health, Turn undead, special mount[/spoiler]
MagewrightWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - Has 10 5th level spells if you have an Int of 30.
- Spell mastery each time a new slot is up is enough for the gems like CoP, animate dead, and dispel magic
- No support, tiny list, and no class features? I'd rather have one less spell level, a mount, and some class features on a decent chassis.
[spoiler]
Dead levels:All but 1 and multiples of 4.
Progression: none besides the spell mastery.
Class Features:none besides the spell mastery[/spoiler]
FighterWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - Anyone can get feats. They are cheap. See my prereq handbook for the free feat diet.
- Fighter only feats really aren't that cool, even without comparing to spells available at a similar level. Your better off whoring more general combat feats.
[spoiler]
Dead levels:3, 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 15, 17, 19.
Progression: fighter feat every even level
Class Features:fighter feat at one[/spoiler]
HealerWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - Clerics still heal better than you, without focusing on it.
- You're supposed to heal with your spells right? Too bad you have a limited list rather than "all conjuration(healing) spells." If you didn't have revivify a psion would heal better than you.
- Supplimentary out of combat healing isn't worth a level and you still have to blow metamagics to not get close for all your healing
- As paladin, your late SLAs are less situational but too sparse. Wouldn't be the level if it were at will, but atleast level 20 doesn't have to pay the costs.
- Your unicorn companion is a weak version of the Special Mount ability
[spoiler]
Dead levels:11,12,14,16,17,18,19.
Progression: full casting
Class Features: healing hands, skill focus(heal), cleanse paralysis, cleanse disease, cleanse fear, cleanse poison, effortless healing, unicorn companion, cleanse blindness, cleanse spirit, cleanse petrification, new limb, new life[/spoiler]
Divine Mind (with Web Enhancements)Why it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - You can now spam astral contructs. Too bad its got nerfed so much
- As before but you have a first level power. I would say choose wisely, but its even worse than the regular feat.
- you can pull the divine feat tricks a paladin can and at the same level. Too bad you don't cast spells for DMM.
[spoiler]
Dead levels: 2, 16.
Progression: +5' aura every other level after.
Class Features:mantle+hidden talent+Entropic ally, aura 5', stygian path, 2nd mantle, change aura(standard action), 2nd aura, 3rd mantle, change aura(move action), change aura(standard action), 3rd aura[/spoiler]
MlarWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - You can make things. Major creation is nice.
- Poisons anyone?
[spoiler]
Dead levels: all.
Progression: 3/4 casting
Class Features:can only cast mending+prestidigation (to objects' color or decoration), magic weapon, make whole, stone shape, minor creation, fabricate, major creation[/spoiler]
SoulbornWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - You can smite if you are MAD, but you are still a big target
- These are very niche. Immunity to strength penalties is the best because evil does it better
- You get your chakras late and you have a crappy list. Welcome to being a soulborn.
- Sharing your immunity is cool but you can only do one at a time so its rarely useful.
- Timeless body is later than the monks and suffers from the same problem.
[spoiler]
Dead levels: 3, 6, 12, 16.
Progression: +1smite/day every multiple of 5,
Class Features: aura+1/day smite, incarnum defense, bonus feat, bonus feat, chakra binds (crown, feet, hands), bonus feat, share incarnum defense 1/day, bonus feat, share incarnum defense 2/day, chakra binds (arms, brow, shoulders), share incarnum defense 3/day, chakra binds (throat, wrist), Timeless body[/spoiler]
EidolonWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - Free multiclassing is cool if you don't build correctly to allow for dips but need feats
- none of the ghost feats are worth it except in specific circumstances: fade for savage progression 1 or melee ghosts might want corrupting and enervating touch. Ghost Glide is suboptimal but flavorful
[spoiler]
Dead levels:3, 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 15, 17, 19.
Progression: [ghost] feats as fighter
Class Features: ghost feat[/spoiler]
LurkWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: [spoiler]
Dead levels: ,.
Progression: Class Features: , [/spoiler]
MonkWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - Not sure what WotC thought the monk's role should be besides 'awesome'. I mean look at all those progressions with no dead levels!
- The chasis is wrong for a meleer. You don't have full BAB, so don't expect to hit anything without severe optimization.
- Your unarmed damage isn't great thanks to exotic weapons, but you can go king of smack if you severely optimize. Too bad you still won't hit
- Dinky AC bonus for your MAD, naked self. Like the above, everyone can have this without the t5 ickiness thanks to a monks belt. It's like core was trying to invalidate the monk class.
- Your speed is an enhancement bonus, so everyone and their mother can do better without wasting precious ECL. What are you going to do with it anyways? Note that spring attack is a trap.
- Little bonuses here and there aren't class features. They are feats. You have paladin-like immunity to diseases, so now you can't become a lycanthrope. Awesome.
- You can heal yourself some and slow fall. Its a good thing you spent levels on this rather than petty cash!
- Spell Resistance that you can't turn off is cool. Nothing like missing that heal or buff!
- Your mild maneuverability of improved evasion, 1/day dimension door, and level rounds/day etherealness are what casters got a long time ago, assuming they even care to blow the money on the ring. Usually, it isn't that important.
- Poison immunity, and tongues come too late and don't get me started on a fort save ability that doesn't work on the cool types anyways.
- Abusing aging penalties comes too late to be useful and being an outsider with sucky DR is not a capstone, no matter what WotC thinks.
[spoiler]
Dead levels:none.
Progression: Flurry of Blows +1 hit per level except 13&17, Unarmed Damage die bump every multiple of 4, +1AC every multiple of 5, +10Speed Bonus every multiple of 3,
Class Features: Bonus feat+flurry of blows+unarmed strike, Bonus feat+evasion, Still mind, Ki strike (magic)+slow fall 20', Purity of body, Bonus feat+slow fall 30', Wholeness of body, Slow fall 40', Improved evasion, Ki strike (lawful)+slow fall 50', Diamond body+greater flurry, Abundant step+slow fall 60', Diamond soul, Slow fall 70', Quivering palm, Ki strike (adamantine)+slow fall 80', Timeless body+tongue of the sun and moon, Slow fall 90', Empty body, Perfect self+slow fall any distance[/spoiler]
Samurai (with Imperious Command feat)Why it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - Mass Staredown is mildly cool with Imperious Command. Unfortunately, Zhentarium Fighter does it better (Swift Action, so you can still attack), and the Dread Pirate and Scarlet Corsair PrCs both provide far superior versions of this ability.
- Samurai 10 with the Fearsome Armor enhancement (DoTU) and the Imperious Command feat can do the double intimidate 4 levels sooner than normal, and send foes cowering for 1 round first. Of course, at that level a Zhentarim fighter with that armor can do a triple intimidate.
[spoiler]
Dead levels: see above, though you might as well use the
web enhancement while your at it.
Progression: see above
Class Features: see above[/spoiler]
NinjaWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - Same problems as the monk on AC bonus. Doesn't even stack without optimization
- Sudden strike is the retarded cousin of sneak attack. See the rogue entry and then try to imagine it sucking more.
- Ki is so flavorful. Quick make it suck! Trapfinding has the same problems rogues face
- The ghost abilities are pretty cool, I admit. Its the real thing that makes you a ninja. Abuse it before your niche fades.
- Great leap doesn't worth with a medium load and your spider climb isn't even really a spider climb.
- The Ghost Mind ability can be bypassed so easily, its worthless
- Ghost sight is only 15 levels too late compared to a warlock. That's not much, is it?
[spoiler]
Dead levels:none. You are awesome like the monk. Right?
Progression: +1AC every multiple of 5, +1d6 sudden strike every odd level including level 1, +2 acrobatics every multiple of 6
Class Features: trapfinding+ki power, ghost step(invisible), poison use, great leap, ki dodge, speed climb, ghost strike, improved poison use, ghost step (ethereal), evasion, ghost mind, ghost sight, greater ki dodge, ghost walk[/spoiler]
BattledancerWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - If the ninja is the inbred monk rogue lovechild, the battledancer is the severly inbred monk plus monk then given away to the circus child.
- Move action Su when threatened give +4 vs fear for 5+cha. Like that helps?
- Congratulations, your speed boost isn't enhancement. Too bad you get less than the monk so it evens out.
- No tumble restrictions. Okay that's good anti-melee stuff. And for the teleporting casters?
- Dancer's Strikes involve blowing a standard action to gain it for only 5+cha rounds. Raise your hand if you like action penalties to be effective in combat! Don't get excited about that (any) either; you merely pick one unchanging type.
- You can water walk three levels after the cleric has been doing it.
- Pounce is cool. Too bad the barbarians did it ten levels ago.
- An AC debuff is okay but this ability only matters if your allies are stupid enough to proc a lot of AoOs. Otherwise +4str or +4dex is better.
- A fly speed is good. It competes well with those 9th level spells, huh?
- +2d6 and crit confirm is again not a capstone.
[spoiler]
Dead levels: 3, 7, 9, 13, 15, 19.
Progression: cha-based AC and unarmed damage as monk. But with full BAB!
Class Features: AC bonus+unarmed strike, battle dancer's performance, +10'ms, dance of the vexing snake, Dancer's strike(magic), dance of the floating step, +20'ms, Dance of the springing tiger, Dancer's strike(alignment), dance of the crushing python, 30'ms, dance of the soaring eagle, dancer's strike(any), dance of the death's embrace[/spoiler]
KnightWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - Blow a swift action to hit harder assuming the opponent meets the criteria of being low CR. Snore.
- Some people get hard ons reading about forcing agro. Its a will save. You might as well charm them, but atleast this ability isn't mind-affecting.
- Reroll on fear assuming you are MAD. Meh
- More must be low CR stuff. Its a dinky fear effect
- Slipper mind, basically
- Ex furiousity is cool but nothing new for the past however many levels.
[spoiler]
Dead levels: 19.
Progression: Fighters challenge +1 every 6 after 1, shield block+1 every 9 after 2
Class Features: Fighters challenge +1+knight's challenge+knight's code, mounted combat+shield block+1, bullwark defense, armor mastery(medium)+test of mettle, bonus feat+vigilant defender, shield ally, call to battle, armor master(heavy), bonus feat, daunting challenge, improved shield ally, bonus feat, beyond loyalty, impetuous endurance, loyal beyond death[/spoiler]
SwashbucklerWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: [spoiler]
Dead levels: ,.
Progression: Class Features: , [/spoiler]
MarinerWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: [spoiler]
Dead levels: ,.
Progression: Class Features: , [/spoiler]
ExpertWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - You are the skill monkey version of a commoner
- Choosing any 10 skills goes a long way if you chose the right ones. Craft? No. Iajitsu Focus? Yes please.
[spoiler]
Dead levels:all.
Progression: none
Class Features: non[/spoiler]
SoulknifeWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: - The base stats on a mind blade aren't great so don't pretend to have an awesome weapon. You don't.
- Even at range (crap 30') don't pretend to do your extra damage since everyone loves being immune to mind-affecting
- The quick draw would be good, except you can only throw the mind blade twice in a round until level 17
- Non crappy shapes still require EWP and are at -1 enhancement bonus. Awesome
- Enhancing your crappy weapon would be cool if you couldn't just by the same thing...
- The feats are fine. Better than the whirlwind silliness anyways.
- Int damage is cool, but its too little too late. First level casters can do that.
[spoiler]
Dead levels:none.
Progression: +1 mind blade every 4 levels Class Features: mind blade+WF+Wild Talent, Throw Mind Blade, Psychic Strike +1d8, Freedraw+Shade Mind Blade, Mind Blade Enhancement +1+Speed of Thought, Psychic Strike +2d8, Bladewind+GWF, Mind blade enhancement +2, Psychic Strike +3d8, Knife to the Soul, Mind Blade Enhancement +3, Psychic strike +4d8, Multiple Throw, Mind Blade Enhancement +4, Psychic Strike +5d8[/spoiler]
NobleWhy it Doesn't Do its Job Well: [spoiler]
Dead levels: ,.
Progression: Class Features: , [/spoiler]