In the spirit of the OP, I'll try to list 4 or 5 folks that I can think of off the top of my head that I'd probably enjoy a RL game with. In no particular order...:
Caelic: Has nice, wacky ideas
Surreal: Helpful, and has some similar interests as me
TreantMonkLvl20: Seems to have experience and fun
Bhu: More, and more wacky, ideas
That would make a party of four with some sort of DM thingy. I'd probably enjoy gaming with most of the posters here, I just thought of those guys first. Half the fun is just in the interaction, and that is harder to gauge over the interwebs; some folks prolly just wouldn't get along...Not me of course; I'm the easiest person in the world to be around. Just ask me and I'll tell ya.