Brilliant Gameologists Forum
General Gab => Off Topic Fun => : Nox_Noctis May 21, 2008, 10:04:18 PM
-
Let's debate these by listing the pro's for each (and con's if we find any).
The Armies:
Cake:
Nox_Noctis
Skydragonknight
Altpersona
Smudgyhandsman
Shadeseraph
Meg
Kai
Entropic Shadow
Dman11235
Pie:
Ninjarabbit
PhoenixInferno
MittenNinja
Josh
Aftercrescent
Cake Pie:
ShaggyShaggs
The "Arguments":
Cake:
delicious
moist
cheese-
layery goodness
birthday-
stripper-
chocolate stuff in ice cream cakes
Boston cream (stolen from Pie)
is not a lie, despite popular belief
cup-
carrot
lemon
weddings
Pie:
lemon meringue
apple
cherry
pumpkin
blueberry
poutang
French silk (which sounds like a terrible innuendo given that we're discussing pies)
pork
chicken pot
frito
pulled pork
Thanksgiving Day
homemade butter crust
adaptable
quiche
meat
strawberry rhubarb
pizza
Cake Pie:
After much debating, a new third party has arisen that may spark great controversy: Cake Pie.
I personally see this as a defilement of all that is cake, but others may contend that it is actually a fusion of all that is good in each - to which I respond, good in pie? Blasphemy!
Come one, come all, and let us settle this! Two baked goods enter, one baked good leaves.
-
Count me in as Pro-cake. Layery goodness vs. consistent meh.
-
+1 cake
+1 cheese
+1 birthday
+1 stripper
-
Yeah, cake is the way to go. That chocolate stuff in ice cream cakes, oh man. :drool
-
Cake, even if it is a lie.
-
Pie
I like all sorts of pie, apple pie, cherry pie, pumpkin pie blueberry pie, not a big fan of pecan pie, but most of all I like the poutang pie ..... if it's good enough for the Rock then its good enough for me
-
Pie
I like all sorts of pie, apple pie, cherry pie, pumpkin pie blueberry pie, not a big fan of pecan pie, but most of all I like the poutang pie ..... if it's good enough for the Rock then its good enough for me
Ah, so the enemy shows itself. Be careful everyone, it's rabbit...and a ninja!
-
Put me down for pie.
-
Put me down for pie.
*eyes narrow*
So, it looks like we're up against Phoenix Inferno. PI King
-
I would eat cake everyday if I wasn't worried about the whole terribly-unhealthy side affect.
There are a few pies I love-- lemon meringue and Boston Cream, but the latter is really a cake anyway, so I am without a doubt in the cake category.
And the cake ISN'T a lie!
-
I'm in on the side of cake. I'm quite taken with cupcakes at the moment actually...
-
French Silk Pie > all.
-
I'm sorry, I know there are ladies out in the audience, but if poontang pie doesn't win the Pie vs That Other Baked Good, then I don't know what will. :P
Damn, the flapping tongue is awesome :)
-
Back when I could eat gluten I was firmly in the pie camp.
An advantage of pie is that you can have savory pies. Pork pies, chicken pot pies, frito pie and my invention: pulled pork pie.
-
my invention: pulled pork pie.
What hath God wrought?
-
+1 Pie.
The cake is a lie. No manner of deception will change this.
The pie is deliciously deceptive, even to the point of masquerading as a cake (Cheesecake, after all, is a type of pie)
-
While that pulled pork pie does sound delicious, I am going to have to go with cake for the reasons of cheese and carrot.
-
And the cake ISN'T a lie!
But they will bake me before they give it to me!
Anyway, the cake is great.
Though I have to say I love cheesecake too. But I prefer lemon cake.
-
Cake reminds me of weddings and they are nice.
-
hair pie, is not sufficient alone to beat cake.
9 times out of 10 its more trouble than its worth.
god forbid it goes bad..
it lowers your iq if your not careful.
-
http://youtube.com/watch?v=3sYGlIbTVB8&feature=related
The Rock educating his millions and millions of fans on Thankgiving Day pie
-
Can't believe we have so many infidels that need smiting!
Gotta go with Pie. I took a pie making class, there is nothing better than a homemade butter crust. Pie is flexible, you can put just about anything in it. Have a quiche in the morning, a meat pie for lunch, and strawberry rhubarb pie for desert at dinner.
A pie for every meal!
-
I think we're all forgetting something very, very important...
Pizza Pie.
-
Do you still like cake? (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-azqXygCzO8)
If you said yes. Watch it again. And again. Until you go over to the pie side.
-
You can put anything in pie. Thus the solution is clear:
Cake pie.
-
Well, due to Boston Cream Pie, cake clearly has the advantage, though French Silk and Lemon Meringue lead pies to a close second. Put me down for cake.
-
Mmmmmmmmmmmm pie! (http://www.weebl.jolt.co.uk/pie.htm)
-
Where I live we have only one word for cake and pie. Is a win-win situation, actually :D
-
hair pie, is not sufficient alone to beat cake.
Hairless pie is.
-
... Let is be known that Meg supports hairless pie. Take that as you will. :couch
-
... Let is be known that Meg supports hairless pie. Take that as you will. :couch
Meg is on the side of cake. JOSH is on the side of hairless pie.
-
Sorry to say this guys, but Apple Pie beats everything
-
I present to you the newest innovations in pie technology (http://pdos.csail.mit.edu.nyud.net:8080/~rsc/ahealy/pi_small.jpg).
-
hair pie, is not sufficient alone to beat cake.
Hairless pie is.
PI, that was in response to this, and meant as an innuendo more than an argument for or against cake or pie. :P
-
cake has already been declared the winner anyway, the whole discussion is pointless...
_____ ' takes the cake'
nothing ever "takes the pie"
the cake is clearly the winner., other wise it would not be the prize.
-
cake has already been declared the winner anyway, the whole discussion is pointless...
_____ ' takes the cake'
nothing ever "takes the pie"
the cake is clearly the winner., other wise it would not be the prize.
Except that that term comes from cakewalks. Yes cake is so undesirable they have to come up with a gimmick to give it away. You can sell pies.
(For people not from 1950 middle America a cakewalk is a really lame contest like musical chairs where instead of taking a seat away you win cake. A contest so lame the term "cakewalk" originates there.)
The best argument hairless pie (sometimes called "shaved mooseknuckle" pie or "purple bulldog lip" pie). Point out the following:
The biggest supporters of "hair" pie:
1) Communists
2) Terrorists
3) French people
Now ask yourself ladies, if you want to be in any of those groups?
That argument is a Piece of pie.
-
er, moose knuckles are not pie related.
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=moose+knuckles (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=moose+knuckles)
-
er, moose knuckles are not pie related.
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=moose+knuckles (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=moose+knuckles)
Scroll down to number 4. And if you still don't know what we're talking about, google "hair pie". :smirk
Edit: I hope I don't get fired for clicking on that at work...
-
Doh!! canada...
so whats the 'canadaian' dude term?
no wait, i dont wanna know..
-
Put me down for pie, also Boston cream pie is a pie not a cake. If any one disagrees go down to Allston Village find out for your self!
There is a bar in Allston Village that serves Boston Cream Pies, and PBR on tap, its the greatest place in the world!
-
Put me down for pie, also Boston cream pie is a pie not a cake. If any one disagrees go down to Allston Village find out for your self!
There is a bar in Allston Village that serves Boston Cream Pies, and PBR on tap, its the greatest place in the world!
You'll never win. I'm a cake supremecist and you'll always be the minority.
-
Put me down for pie, also Boston cream pie is a pie not a cake. If any one disagrees go down to Allston Village find out for your self!
There is a bar in Allston Village that serves Boston Cream Pies, and PBR on tap, its the greatest place in the world!
You'll never win. I'm a cake supremecist and you'll always be the minority.
Yeah but the minority always get extra scholarships.
-
We of the glorious and holy nation of Eijilund have long debated over this topic, and using the finest minds of magic and science have achieved harmony of pie and cake. We hereby officially announce our support of Shaggy and his Cakepie. The delicious nature of both cake and pie will be behind you and the forces of 300 of our finest elite cooks.
Tonight we dine with cakepie!
-
I'm pro-cake. Seems to be a little easier to eat.
-
We of the glorious and holy nation of Eijilund have long debated over this topic, and using the finest minds of magic and science have achieved harmony of pie and cake. We hereby officially announce our support of Shaggy and his Cakepie. The delicious nature of both cake and pie will be behind you and the forces of 300 of our finest elite cooks.
Tonight we dine with cakepie!
Blasphemers! Off with their heads! (Yes, I'm turning this into a make-believe war. I went there. It's like being five years old again.)
-
Fuck cakepie. screen shot or it didn't happen.
-
Cake. Cause I discovered Tiramisu cupcakes, and nothing pie based could ever come so close to divinity.
Also cupcakes in and of themselves are pretty darn awesome.
-
Pie.
-
Oh, Caketown, duh. I can't believe we forgot that. :sparta
-
Fuck cakepie. screen shot or it didn't happen.
O RLY? Cakepie GO! (http://www.flickr.com/photos/sazerac/2072296906/)
-
It looks utterly disgusting, to be quite honest, an abomination against all that is cake or pie (which wasn't much in the case of pie). I deem cakepie inferior to either of the aforementioned baked goods. [Nox used Judgment. It's super-effective! Cakepie lost 9001% of its health. Cakepie fainted.]
-
I give you that, it was an unappitesing flavor but it exists. Now, there were some delicious looking cakepies I found, but non with screenshots of clearly cakey and pie like insides (not in the same shot anyway).
I need some lemon pie with vanilla cake, mm mmm.
-
To quite the prophet Stewie, that "cakepie" looks like a culinary abortion.
-
Pie.
nuff said.
-
Err, pie, duh. What self respecting orc would die in the defense of a cake?
Also, blueberry pie is the bestest.
-
i used to be a cake man. However, now I do not eat sugar and sugar-free pie is much better than sugar free cake.
-
Since any self-respecting cheesecake is baked and has a crust and a filling, I'm in the pie camp. I'm tempted by the underdog/anarchist movement that is cakepie, but I have to go with pie.
-
Since any self-respecting cheesecake is baked and has a crust and a filling, I'm in the pie camp. I'm tempted by the underdog/anarchist movement that is cakepie, but I have to go with pie.
My mother's (actually, the recipe is my grandmother's or perhaps older still) cheesecake uses (nor needs) no filling nor crust (though I do admit I love the texture of crust on those cheesecakes that have it), just gustatory goodness. It's absolutely delicious (to the point that people in the neighborhood actually ask her if she can make it for various events they attend or organize).
-
The mixing of Cake and Pie is an affront to God.
While I can accept the existence of Cake, I would not want my precious Pie to be mixing with Cake.
Separate but Equal.
-
The mixing of Cake and Pie is an affront to God.
While I can accept the existence of Cake, I would not want my precious Pie to be mixing with Cake.
Separate but Equal.
The Supreme Court would like a word with you. :P
-
The Supreme Court would like a word with you. :P
Which Supreme Court? I distinctly remember the current incarnation passing Pie power as constitutional :P
-
Cake slaves! Throw off the shackles of your oppresive overlords! Come to the pie side! We have...pie.
-
Cake slaves! Throw off the shackles of your oppresive overlords! Come to the pie side! We have...pie.
Hey, some of us like cake!
-
Hey, some of us like cake!
And we won't hold your bad judgment against you. We are forgiving of those who have never had the opportunit to enjoy pie. Come on over to the pie side; it's better here.